Evolution and Cancer

Worksheet


I. Cancer is a disorder that involves the transformation of normal benign body cells into malignant rapidly dividing cells. Our Evolution and Cancer Quest begins with an examination of cells. First, let's define;

What is Cancer?

 1. In the text box below briefly summarize what is cancer? Click on the text box to activate it. Type in your answer. Click off the box to deactivate it.

                                    

 

2. List three characteristics that would label cell growth as cancerous. Click on the text box to activate it. Type in your answer. Click off the box to deactivate it.

a.
b.
c.

 

II. How Cancer Grows extends the What is Cancer? section and will explain some of the molecular biology of the disease. It is a bit more technical, but necessary if you are to effectively grasp the implications of this unfolding Evolution Cancer Quest.

  How Cancer Grows

When you've finished the presentation, answer the following two questions . Click on the box next to the correct answers and place an X in them.

 

1. The first genetic mutation in the early stages of carcinoma (epithelial cancer) formation can take different forms such as: (3 answers)

a. causing cells to reproduce when the replacement, or production, of cells isn't necessary.

b. causing cells to penetrate through the tissue's basement membrane and invade the surrounding tissue.

c. causing cells to stimulate angiogenesis and recruit blood vessels to bring nourishment to the developing tumor.

d. causing cells not to self-destruct when they should.

 

2. For a cell to become cancerous it generally requires a series of more than two mutations to occur.

a. True   b. False.

 


For Your Information

1.  There is growing evidence that genes can play a primary role in development of some cancers. All of the following genetic factors could contribute to the development of cancer in some people.

a. DNA repair enzymes that are inefficient in their correction of genetic defects.

b. Enzymes that are incapable of breaking down certain molecules that oxidize and generate carcinogenic intermediates.

c. Missing enzymes that breakdown carcinogenic polycyclic hydrocarbons (PAHs).

d. Carcinogenic molecules that bind to specific cell receptors and change cell chemistry.

 

2.  The following factors are known contribute to the development of cancer in some people.

a. Infants being exposed to pesticides.

b. Immune system deficiencies in older people

c. Infant's increased intake of amounts of carcinogens in breast milk.

 BACK Home

III.

Breast Cancer Etiology from a Darwinian Perspective

Summarized from Katherine E. Wynne-Edwards, Ph.D, 2001

Read the opening paragraph Darwinian Medicine of Dr. Wynne-Edwards summary.

1. In the text box below briefly state the main concern of women who have survived breast cancer.

Darwinian Medicine

2. The main risk factors for this form of cancer appear to be internal-age is the biggest single determining factor, followed closely by age at first pregnancy.

a.True b. False

3. Briefly explain below what Dr. Wynne-Edwards did to find a common mechanism for breast cancer and how it was received by medical professionals.

Darwinian Medicine

Read the section headed Cancer from the Wynne-Edwards' paper and respond to the questions below.

4. What, according to Dr. Wynne-Edwards, are the five things a cell line has to achieve to become cancerous?

1a.

2a.

3a.

4a.

5a.

Darwinian Medicine

5. Briefly explain what age has to do with one's chances of getting cancer.

6. What is estrogen and what does it have to do with someone's chances of getting cancer?

Darwinian Medicine

Read Evolutionary Perspectives on Reproduction. Answer the questions below.

7. According to Dr. Wynne-Edwards interpretation of "primitive" humans, reproductive cycles of "modern" humans have been changed so dramatically that females are exposed to a great deal more estrogen than their ancestors.

a.True b. False

8. What is the correlation between ovulation and estrogen? How, according to Dr. Wynne-Edwards, does it contribute to causing breast cancer?

Darwinian Medicine

Read How Estrogen Contributes to Cancer in the Breast . Respond the the following questions.

9. When a woman goes through puberty, the cells in her breasts do not respond to estrogen to develop and proliferate.

a.True b. False

10. Between puberty and first pregnancy, the cells of the breast are primed to respond to estrogen, which makes

a. the estrogen ineffective.

b. that particular hormone an extremely weak signal for those cells.

c. that particular hormone a powerful signal for those cells.

d. none of the above.

Darwinian Medicine

11. Many forms of breast cancer have been found to grow in response to estrogen, and women who have breast cancer are often treated with anti-estrogens.

a.True b. False


Let's pause here and pursue an anti-estrogen. Read the first two parts of Tamoxifen as a Treatment for Breast Cancer, What is tamoxifen? and How does tamoxifen work in preventing or delaying breast cancer recurrence?, then answer the question below.

12. What is tamoxifen and can it possibly prevent cancer from occurring?


Now, let's return to the Darwinian Medicine text and finish reading the last section Age of First Pregnancy, then answer the following questions.

13. The older a woman is when she has her first child, the lower her chance of developing breast cancer at any point in her life.

a.True b. False

14. In between puberty and first pregancy, while the cells in the breast are waiting for the estrogen signal to undergo the final stage of development

a. the mitotic rate of those cells is ten times higher than cells that have already reached the final stage.

b. the mitotic rate of those cells is twenty times higher than cells that have already reached the final stage.

c. the mitotic rate of those cells is forty times higher than cells that have already reached the final stage.

d. none of the above.

Darwinian Medicine

15. The longer a woman waits before having her first child, the longer her breast cells undergo rapid division.

a.True b. False

16. Women who have children shortly after puberty go immediately to the final stage of breast development where the mitotic rate (and therefore the chance of mutations) is much lower.

a.True b. False

Return to Darwinian Medicine. You and your partner discuss the four questions provided by Dr. Wynne-Edwards. After you have talked to one another be prepared for a classroom discussion that will examine these same questions.

Back Home

Related Links:

Evolutionary Biology Resources

This is a list of cyberresources from the Internet that deal with interesting issues in Evolutionary Biology. They were assembled to provide supplemental materials for a course in Evolutionary Biology at Saint Anselm College.

What is Darwinian Medicine?

A brief overview of: Why We Get Sick: The New Science of Darwinian Medicine by Randolph Nesse and George Williams, Vintage Books, 1996.

Darwinian Evolutionary Medicine

An editorial from the Southern Medical Journal on Darwinian (Evolutionary) Medicine

Darwinian Medicine Website

This Website was first created for Science Week 1997, after which it has continued to be devoted to Darwinian Medicine; under constant review and open to your ideas and comments.

Paul Ewald:Infectious Disease and the Evolution of Virulence

The transcript of an interview with Paul Ewald on the PBS Evolution site.

Infectious Disease as an Evolutionary Paradigm

Joshua Lederberg, Sackler Foundation Scholar, Rockefeller University, New York, New York, USA

The basic principles of genetics and evolution apply equally to human hosts and to emerging infections, in which foodborne outbreaks play an important and growing role. However, we are dealing with a very complicated coevolutionary process in which infectious agent outcomes range from mutual annihilation to mutual integration and resynthesis of a new species. In our race against microbial evolution, new molecular biology tools will help us study the past; education and a global public health perspective will help us deal better with the future.

Deadly Evolution

Deadly Evolution is an audio file from Sound Print produced by Loretta Williams and Marjorie Centofanti.

A flu suddenly becomes deadly and kills more than 20 million people. Malaria, once easily treated, has become one of the most persistent diseases of our time. Even new viruses such as HIV exhibit variations in the virus's ability to kill. A variety of factors influence the spread and deadliness of disease, but some biologists think a critical influence has been overlooked--evolution. Producers Marjorie Centofanti and Loretta Williams explore the evolution theories that could lead to change in the treatment of infectious disease.

Learn more about the scientists featured in this program: Allen Herre shares a summary of an article on his virulence research, Paul Ewald contributes excerpts from his bibliography, and Phyllis Kanki describes her experiences as an HIV/AIDS researcher in Senegal.